Perpetual Talent Solutions has been named to the 2026 Best of Executive Search list View Recognition

eCommerce Executive Search
in Indianapolis

Partner-led retained search for the directors, vice presidents and C-suite executives who lead Central Indiana's direct-to-consumer platforms, digital marketplaces and eCommerce fulfillment networks.

30+ Years Combined executive recruiting experience
Partner-Led From intake through offer
Houston-Based Serving clients nationwide

Perpetual Talent Solutions is a Houston-based eCommerce executive search firm conducting retained searches for companies across the Indianapolis metro, from Carmel and Fishers to Plainfield and McCordsville. We recruit directors, vice presidents and C-suite executives accountable for direct-to-consumer revenue, marketplace growth, digital commerce strategy and the fulfillment operations behind every online order.

Online commerce, led and shipped from Central Indiana.

Central Indiana’s eCommerce leadership roles take distinctive forms. Eli Lilly, headquartered in Indianapolis, operates LillyDirect, its direct-to-consumer healthcare platform. OPENLANE runs digital marketplaces for wholesale used vehicles from Carmel. SupplyKick, based in Fishers, helps consumer product companies sell on Amazon, and increasingly on Walmart and other marketplaces.

Fulfillment is the other half of the local picture. Walmart’s McCordsville fulfillment center covers 2.2 million square feet. FedEx runs its second national air hub at Indianapolis International Airport. As eCommerce executive recruiters, our partners look for executives who tie online growth targets to fulfillment cost and delivery speed. We contact them directly and in confidence, whether or not they are open to a move.

Indianapolis eCommerce Search Expertise

Direct-to-Consumer Platforms

Executive search for companies that sell directly to consumers online, including in regulated categories. Eli Lilly’s LillyDirect platform shows how far DTC models now reach beyond apparel and beauty.

We recruit executives with demonstrated success in building direct customer relationships online, from first order to repeat purchase, and in the compliance demands of selling regulated products online.

Online Marketplaces & Marketplace Sellers

Leadership recruiting for digital marketplaces and the companies that help other businesses sell on them. OPENLANE operates online marketplaces where dealers buy and sell used vehicles wholesale. SupplyKick, a full-service Amazon agency, helps product companies sell on Amazon, and increasingly on Walmart and other marketplaces.

We recruit marketplace executives who can grow buyer and seller participation, pricing discipline and trust on business-to-business and consumer platforms.

Digital Commerce Leadership for Established Companies

Leadership recruiting for the digital commerce operations of established consumer businesses that sell from Central Indiana. FullBeauty Brands runs the catalog and online business for its apparel brands from fulfillment centers in Indianapolis and Plainfield. For executives at companies like this, the task is growing online sales while keeping long-standing catalog customers.

We recruit digital commerce executives who lift online sales within complex companies and keep that growth consistent with commercial, merchandising and customer goals.

Fulfillment & Air Hub Networks

Recruiting fulfillment executives for a distribution market where space is tightening. According to Cushman & Wakefield’s latest report, Indianapolis industrial vacancy has fallen to 5.2%, its lowest level in four years.

We recruit directors, vice presidents and C-suite executives who set fulfillment strategy and oversee site expansion, automation and parcel and air partnerships.

Roles We Recruit For

Fulfillment & Distribution Operations

  • Chief Operating Officer
  • Chief Fulfillment Officer
  • Vice President, Fulfillment
  • Regional Distribution Center Director
  • Head of Warehouse Operations

Digital Commerce & Revenue

  • Chief Executive Officer / President
  • Chief Digital Officer
  • Chief eCommerce Officer
  • Chief Marketing Officer
  • Vice President, Digital Growth
  • Head of Marketplaces
  • Head of Sales, Fulfillment Services

Planning, Inventory & Returns

  • Vice President, Supply Chain
  • Head of Inventory Strategy
  • Director, Reverse Logistics
  • Sales & Operations Planning Leader

Corporate & Enabling Functions

  • Chief Financial Officer
  • Chief Technology Officer
  • Vice President, Human Resources
  • Head of Customer Experience

Questions About eCommerce Executive Search in Indianapolis

Why retain an eCommerce executive search firm instead of using an eCommerce recruitment agency or headhunter in Indianapolis?

Senior eCommerce executives in Central Indiana are usually employed, performing well and not reading job postings. Retained executive search commits a partner to the whole assignment: defining the role, mapping executives in Indianapolis and other markets, approaching them directly and assessing them before you meet anyone. Unlike traditional contingency recruiting, the engagement is defined at the outset and one partner stays with it until your new executive has signed. For a hire who will shape online revenue for years, that continuity matters.

How do I find the right eCommerce executive recruiter or headhunter to work with?

Begin with two questions: how senior is the hire, and what kind of commerce will they lead? A firm that recruits directors, vice presidents and C-suite executives should be able to explain how it will build a candidate list for your model, whether that is DTC, marketplace or fulfillment. Find out which partner will personally lead your search and how progress will be reported. Ask about off-limits policies too: we never recruit executives from our own clients.

Can you recruit eCommerce executives for a healthcare or pharmaceutical company selling direct to consumers?

Yes. Direct-to-consumer models now extend into healthcare, as Eli Lilly’s LillyDirect platform shows. These roles combine online customer experience with pharmacy partners, self-pay pricing and regulatory review. We recruit executives with demonstrated success in growing DTC channels who have also worked in compliance-heavy categories, or who can show exactly how they would adapt.

Do you recruit marketplace executives for business-to-business platforms?

Yes. Not every digital marketplace sells to consumers. OPENLANE, based in Carmel, runs digital marketplaces where dealers trade used vehicles wholesale. Executives for platforms of this kind need to grow participation on both sides, build trust in each transaction and manage the logistics behind it. Our executive searches span consumer marketplaces, B2B platforms and the firms that help other companies sell on Amazon and other marketplaces.

Will eCommerce executives from larger markets relocate to Indianapolis?

Many will, when the role and the company’s plans are compelling. According to the latest U.S. Census Bureau estimates, the Indianapolis-Carmel-Greenwood metro has 2,205,695 residents, up from 2,089,651 at the start of the decade. We discuss relocation, hybrid arrangements and family considerations with candidates from the first call. Our searches reach nationally whenever the strongest executive for a Central Indiana role lives elsewhere.

Do you search for fulfillment executives to oversee sites in Plainfield, Avon or McCordsville?

Yes. Fulfillment centers across Hendricks and Hancock counties include Walmart’s site in McCordsville and FullBeauty Brands’ operation in Plainfield. According to Cushman & Wakefield’s latest report, 8.9 million square feet of industrial space is under construction in the Indianapolis market. That pipeline creates demand for executives who can open new sites, automate existing ones and protect delivery promises as volume grows. We recruit directors, vice presidents and C-suite executives accountable for the performance of networks like these.

Do your eCommerce placements come with a guarantee?

Yes. Our placement guarantee runs three to six months, with the period set by role level. Our published executive placement success rate is above 95%.

What executive roles do your eCommerce searches in Indianapolis include?

Our executive searches span Head of DTC, VP of Marketplace, VP of eCommerce, Chief Commerce Officer, Chief Digital Officer, VP of Digital Marketing, VP of Fulfillment and VP of Customer Experience roles. We also recruit technology, product, analytics and finance executives whose work drives online revenue. These searches serve digitally native companies, online marketplaces, healthcare DTC platforms and the digital commerce operations of established consumer businesses across Central Indiana.

Who Do You Need to Bring On Board?

Every conversation starts with your business priorities, not a sales pitch. Tell us about the leadership hire you are planning or the challenge you need to solve and we will give you a candid assessment of the role, the market and whether we are the right fit.

Speak with a Managing Partner